La Capricciosa Pizza in Greenport

Great slices, lots of drink choices and right near the ferry. Reasonably priced and good service.

The green goddess pizza was generously heaped with fresh toppings and the crust thickness was just the way I like it. I ordered online and appreciated the encouragement to stay safe by calling from my car at arrival to have my pizza brought out to me.

Cool place, didn't like the fact that if you ordered a drink at the bar you couldn't sit at the bar. The kale salad was awesome, and the pizza wasn't half bad either. I really liked the atmosphere.

excellent slices, great place for an affordable dinner if you want to sit down. They provide a generous complimentary salad and bread when you order an entree from their sit-down section.

AMAZING FOOD!! WOULD RECOMMEND!!

This was one of the best pizzas I have eaten in years and I have been eating pizza for over 67 years. Perfect thin crust is key to any great pizza and La Capricciosa has it down pat. ♥️🍕 ⭐⭐⭐⭐🌟🌟

Excellent pizza and homemade garlic knots with lots of garlic bits, not powder. Terrific handmade fried mozzarella with homemade breading. Not sticks, but more like cut pieces of mozzarella. Delicious!

Best pizza. Around .

Both the thin crust and deep dish are amazing! Can't go wrong with either! I am from Chicago area and previous lived outside NY, so I know what good pizza tastes like and this is eat! I'm have quite the appetite so I order thin and deep dish here to split.

First time ate here. It was absolutely amazing pizza i was ordered.

Very nice staff. Pizza was good. Everyone loved the BBQ Chicken.

The deep dish pizza is amazing I enjoyed every bite.The place can get crowded but that's because their services and pizza are pretty good. If you are looking to have a good pizza this is a great place.

((I wish I didn’t have to put a star because they don’t even deserve ONE star. That’s how HORRIBLE it was!!!!))I used to like Brick Oven, was always the place I went to when I came home...went tonite thinking for the best but ordered a pie with sausage and onions, crispy...there was barely any onions (not even worth the charge they made) on it and “crispy” they think “burnt to crap”. Crust was burnt as anything, so tough. And when I went in to pick up one girl asked me what I was there for I say pick up then she turned around and ignored me. Next girl asked me “do you know what you ordered?” Of course I do!! I called it in...so terrible. I’m heart broken. Not the same place I remembered. Won’t go back. I do not recommended it at all.

My go-to deep dish is the margherita plus and the pollo for thin crust. They also have a really yummy garlic bread (it's actually like a mini pizza) and wings as well. Love this place and will keep going back for more!

The pizza is a bit on the pricey side, but if you want to treat yourself, this Is the place. The flavors are also interesting and complex, so I recommend trying something different.

Excellent food and the personnel are very friendly.

I don't eat a lot of pizza but when I do it's little star. Good pizza, good service, good times.

The pizza was really good we a heart shape pizza it was so cute and delicius,but the guy in front making the pizza was the best really friendly he even let my kids made a mini pizza best pizza place we ever been.

I visit this place a lot since I work in the area. I got to say the service is always great and they keep the spot neat consistently. Prices are fair and they serve big portions.

Absolutely one of the best pizzas I've enjoyed in years including those from New York City. Perfect crust, perfect balance of cheese and sauce.The only negative thing I can think of is that this lovely restaurant is 45 miles from my home so no home delivery.😁

The pizza from this place is amazing. I rarely write reviews based on my first experience with any place but the pizza was so good..it warranted a on the spot review. The thin crust is just perfect. It has the right amount of chew and crispyness. The topping on the Italian Combo are just perfect.

Excellent food at a good price. The fried calamari was perfect. Amazing red sauce. Good size portions. Ivan our waiter was attentive but not overbearing. Definitely would come again.

Absolutely wonderful Italian food. I wouldn't order their chicken fingers again, but every single other things we've had is amazing. I live on Shelter Island and it is well worth the ferry ride to pick up a really good pizza. (Though, Isola on the island is also really good, just more of a sit-down spot)

By far the best pizza I've ever had in my whole life!! Always worth the wait. You can't go wrong with whatever you order. I normally wouldn't do a plain cheese pizza, but their cheese pizza may be the best pizza. The crust is perfectly crispy. Great tomato sauce. Great cheese. They use quality, fresh ingredients. Just thinking about it makes me hungry.

They have a large variety of pizza choices by the slice or the whole pie. Also many other choices of great pasta dishes too. Chicken Parmesan or Piccata just to name a few. Great appetizers as well...

Hate is a strong word, so i wouldnt say I hated it.. But that being said.. Their business certainly has room for improvement. Great food. Awful etiquette. =/

I always stop by purchasing some food in this place. I liked the fast customer service and well made food. Fantastic work.

I was uncertain when I saw they only had two sizes 9" or 12". However, when the pizza came out it was more like a 14". We ordered the thin crust. The pizza was crispy and tasty. A little on the pricey side for pizza but definitely worth it!!

Excellent pizza and arugula salad delivered by Caviar. Very confusing situation tho-NY website says they only deliver through Door Dash and Postmates. But those sites only show a mixed greens salad.

The pizza is well balanced in ingredients and flavor with a crisp crust. Have been to quite a few pizza places where they do not give enough sauce, was worried it was a new trend going on to cheap out on the sauce. Not here, plus their pasta dish was good, along with their salad and homemade tomato vinaigrette And fresh garlic bread .

We met with friends at this place for lunch. we heard about this spot from a lot of people. Well, it was a winning. The staff members were extremely nice and we felt very good. The meal was yummy. We had a great time and we will definitely return to this restaurant. Highly recommended.

Oh my goodness this is one of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. This had a thicker crust and I used to not be a crust person, but I could not stop eating it. So half of this is just pepperoni and the other half is pepperoni and sausage. We ate this entire thing so quickly. It was delicious and I have dreamed about this pizza many times. The pizza sauce was so good and the cheese perfectly melted. Yum. I would Highly recommend eating here!

American-style pizza with an amazing selection of slices. Super friendly & helpful staff. Their garlic knots are to die for! Highly recommended!!

Best pizza in Greenport. Okay. Tied with 1943 which is a very different style. Both excellent.

Huge portions and most important.. delicious.

Excellent pizza, & nice place to sit after walking the village. Staff was helpful when we needed pizza cut for our toddler. My husband loved the pepperoni pizza with garlic knot crust!

Good local pizza joint with pleasant staff.

First time ordering from here. The lady on the phone taking my order was really polite and helpful with my questions. The lasagna was absolutely AMAZING! The right amount of beef, ricotta and tomato sauce. The penne and broccoli in the garlic and oil was delicious. Portions were beyond generous and me and my family ate well. Will definitely be ordering from here again! Until then, I'll be dreaming of the lasagna!

Love the pizza, salad and pasta. Easy to order, fast and great cook Elias!

Classy joint. Good, organized service, great food. Nothing more to say, this place is great! Been on my bday twice.

The pizza here was fantastic, I love the thin crust and flavor comes with a kick. Highly recommended and I will definitely be back!

Pizza was very good, calzones too have us free desert that was great. Thank you so much. Very friendly as well.

Defiantly lived up to their 4.5 stars they will get to 5 real quick! Deep dish pizza lives up to its name! Wow! Very very tasty and delicious!! Whoooo!

Great place for dinner. The Baked Brie with apricot compote, roasted pepitas, roasted garlic, sage, toast is delicious. The pork belly appetizer and short ribs dinner are also good choices.

Really great pizza! I love how they have deep dish and thin crust options. They even have vegan cheese which is an amazing plus!

Great Restaurant. Had dinner there this evening. Absolutely wonderful food. SHRIMP Francese and Veal Parm. Large portions - out of this world. Service is Excellent and Moderate Prices.

Thinner crust pizza but toppings well distributed and great taste! Had sanitizer in the restaurant and guests were waiting outside for pick up. Would go again.

I constantly come by grabbing some food in this spot. I enjoy the swift customer service and well made dishes. Great work.

BBQ Chicken pizza and the regular cheese pizzas were both delicious. The store is small, but clean and well organized. Employees are friendly and efficient. The pizzas were thin crust, and crispy, just the way I like it. There is nice outdoor seating also.

Highly recommend their Happy Hour: yummy wings and garlic bread pizza! Usually 5-6:30 weekdays.